Nonfiction: History, Politics, Food
Ruin Their Crops on the Ground: The Politics of Food in the United States, from the Trail of Tears to School Lunch by Andrea Freeman
Food is a source of nourishment and joy for a lot of people but in Ruin their Crops on the Ground, Freeman also tracks how the U.S. government has used food policy as a form of control and oppression.
The title is adapted from the words of George Washington when he sought to subjugate Native American nations, in this case the Iroquois. Freeman says, “Food destruction was so central to settlers’ treatment of Indigenous people that in 1779 George Washington ordered that his troops ‘destroy their crops now in the ground’” in a way that prevented them from returning and starting all over again. And there are more historical events that support Freeman’s urgent message about food politics.
A chapter titled, “Weapons of Health Destruction” tells the story of “frybread,” a deep-fried concoction of sugar, lard, and government-dispensed flour that became a staple of forcefully relocated Native Americans’ diet, and led directly to obesity, diabetes, and other health issues. In “Survival Pending Revolution,” the history of the enslaved people who are brutally over-worked on starvation rations is recounted. And despite the Emancipation Proclamation, the practice of “sharecropping” meant that formerly enslaved people were no better off in terms of food availability. “Black sharecroppers who worked for white landowners largely returned to the restricted diets they ate during enslavement.”
Freeman also describes the double-edged sword of School Lunch Programs: free lunch to those who cannot afford it, which comes with the built-in social stigma for recipients. Inevitably, food options in school lunches are highly processed and unhealthy. Who is making these food choices? Politicians, lobbyists, and powerful corporations!
“Corporations do not feel compassion. Sickness and loss do not move them. Appealing to their humanity is not an effective political strategy.”
There are more than 40 pages of notes and bibliographic references which can direct readers to more research. I only wish Freeman would have included charts and graphs instead of including statistics in the narrative.
“Attaching work requirements to government benefits reflects a belief that social assistance is not a right of citizenship but a gift that its recipients must earn. It insists that poverty is not an accident of birth and social circumstances but a reflection of individuals’ bad choices or capabilities.”
As I read this book, I was unable to suppress a growing sense of emotional urgency regarding food and the feeding of America’s population across all socioeconomic classes! Ruin Their Crops on the Ground is certainly thought-provoking and motivates me to continue volunteering in our community food pantry.

Graphic Nonfiction: History, Mental Health
Ten Days in a Mad-House by Brad Ricca (Adapter), Courtney Sieh (Illustrator), Nellie Bly
"I said I could and I would. And I did." – Nellie Bly
Publisher’s Description: “While working for Joseph Pulitzer's newspaper in 1887, Nellie Bly began an undercover investigation into the local Women's Lunatic Asylum on Blackwell Island. Intent on seeing what life was like on the inside, Bly fooled trained physicians into thinking she was insane—a task too easily achieved—and had herself committed. In her ten days at the asylum, Bly witnessed horrifying conditions: the food was inedible, the women were forced into labor for the staff, the nurses and doctors were cruel or indifferent, and many of the women held there had no mental disorder of any kind.”
Bly recounted the shameful abuse, neglect, and hazardous conditions to be found in the Asylum. After her story was published, a grand jury was convened to investigate her “allegations.” The Asylum staff did the classic switcheroo of inviting tours after cleaning everything up and hiding those patients who were in the worst shape. Critics didn't buy it. While the grand jury made no charges against the Asylum, Nellie Bly’s reporting eventually resulted in sweeping changes in the care and oversight of vulnerable patients.
This fascinating true account is hard to believe at times, and, yet, difficult to stop reading! Bly’s experience in Ten Days in a Mad-House also became the standard for so many future fictional accounts of hospital wards like One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. With this graphic adaptation, I think the main events are presented logically while the illustrations add a visual context for the time, particularly the women’s hairdos and clothing. This was a quick but informative read.
“I answered the summons of the grand jury with pleasure, because I longed to help those of God's most unfortunate children whom I had left prisoners behind me. If I could not bring them that boon of all boons, liberty, I hoped at least to influence others to make life more bearable for them.” – Nellie Bly